BestCarAudio.com

Showcasing the Best in the Mobile Enhancement Industry

Showcasing the Best in the Mobile Enhancement Industry
  • Upgrades
    • Marine Audio
    • Motorcycle Audio
  • Articles
    • Bluetooth
    • Car Audio
    • Motorcycle Audio
    • Navigation
    • Remote Starter
    • Satellite Radio
    • Smartphone Integration
    • Test Drive Product Reviews
    • Vehicle Insights
  • Profiles
    • Installation Profiles
    • Installer Profiles
    • Retailer Profiles
    • Vendor Profiles
  • Products
  • Dealer Locator
  • Shop
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • 0 items
Home » ARTICLES » Understanding Speaker Quality: Inexpensive Replacement Speakers
Arc Audio

Understanding Speaker Quality: Inexpensive Replacement Speakers

August 24, 2022 By Dave MacKinnon

Replacement Speaker Quality

A while back, we took a close look at the harmonic distortion performance of a 6.5-inch door speaker from a Honda Civic. We measured the Theile/Small parameters and the driver’s impedance curve. Next, we looked at how much distortion the speaker created at different drive levels. If you haven’t read that article, it’s a bit of a prerequisite for this one. You can find it here: https://www.bestcaraudio.com/understanding-speaker-quality-oem-speakers/

In this article, we will do the same analysis on a very inexpensive dual-cone replacement speaker called the AW-660SP. This speaker doesn’t have a tweeter but instead includes a small V-shaped cone attached to the center of the speaker, often referred to as a Whizzer cone. The primary purpose of a Whizzer cone is to improve high-frequency output. More specifically, the small diameter helps improve off-axis high-frequency performance. In a different article, we’ll look at how the cone affects off-axis performance.

Replacement Speaker Quality
The integrated Whizzer helps with high-frequency output.

The speaker is based on a thin-gauge stamped steel basket. Given the mounting hole locations and overall diameter, it would be better to describe this as a 6-inch speaker than a 6.5-inch class driver. The woofer cone is injection-molded polypropylene, and its outer edge is attached to the basket with a closed-cell foam surround. The driver is rated to handle 30 watts of power.

Replacement Speaker Quality
There’s nothing of interest to note on the rear of the speaker in terms of cooling or pressure-reducing technologies.

Thiele/Small Parameter Measurements

After experiencing ongoing software and customer service frustrations with my Clio Pocket, I purchased a used Smith & Larson Woofer Tester II to make Thiele/Small measurements. I’ve been using their Woofer Tester products for decades and love their speed and accuracy. Using the added-mass method to calculate driver compliance, I measured the following Thiele/Small parameters.

Replacement Speaker Quality

Any time I have a brand-new driver in the lab, I measure the parameters fresh out of the package and again after 10 to 15 hours of breaking in to see whether the specifications change. There’s nothing wrong with the values changing. I like to know’ whether they do so I can share that information with our readers. This driver didn’t change as the Fs dropped from around 92 hertz to just under 90, and the Vas decreased from 8.21 to 8.03 liters.

It’s worth noting that this speaker has the highest Qts I’ve measured to date at 2.79. This will produce a bump in the low midbass frequencies even with modest power as this is intended as an affordable OE replacement driver; that likely isn’t a bad thing as it will add some warmth to the sound. This isn’t suitable for any sound quality or audiophile application.

Replacement Speaker Quality
Impedance graph of the Metra AW-660SP.

The impedance graph shows the moderately wide spike at the driver’s resonance frequency and a slight shift in the phase response plot between 800 and 1 kHz.

I finished the bench evaluation by simulating the speaker functionality in a 3-cubic-foot sealed enclosure that would mimic the effectively infinite baffle door mounting location. As mentioned, the extremely high Qts value of the driver shows up as a bump in the response just above 100 Hz.

Replacement Speaker Quality
Predicted response of the AW-660SP in a 3-cubic-foot sealed enclosure.

Measuring Speaker Distortion at Different Drive Levels

In my last test of the Honda speaker, I placed the microphone 1 meter from the cone. Unfortunately, I am testing in a large room, not an anechoic chamber. As such, some reflections have to be dealt with. Of note, the Honda speaker test shows a significant dip in the response around 130 hertz. That isn’t a characteristic of the speaker – it’s a cancellation in the room. For this test, I moved the microphone closer to the speaker cone. Specifically, it’s 17 cm away from the mounting surface. This is closer to a near-field measurement and results in a smoother response through the midbass region. This change in measurement distance means you can’t compare the output levels of the two drivers. The distortion characteristics will remain accurate for the different drive levels. I think I’ll revisit the Honda speaker and clone the measurements used in this article.

I took the first sweep with the system calibrated to produce a drive level of 0.1 watt or -9.97 dBW.

Replacement Speaker Quality
AW-660SP frequency response and total harmonic distortion at 0.1 watt (red).

If you think worrying about source units, processors and speaker quality is essential to creating an audio system that sounds amazing, you might want to think about speaker quality. With only 1/10th of a watt, we see distortion levels 50 dB below the fundamental in the midrange and 35 dB below the bass range. Let’s look at the distortion levels in percentage values at several frequencies. At 50 Hz, the little woofer produced 8.56% distortion. Up at 200 Hz, the distortion dropped to 1.05%. In the upper midrange at 500 Hz, distortion was 0.35%. At the top end of the useful range of a midrange driver of this size, I measured 0.32% and 0.22% distortion at 2 kHz and 4 kHz, respectively.

Replacement Speaker Quality
AW-660SP frequency response and total harmonic distortion at 0.4 watt (green).

I increased the output of the amplifier by about 6 dB to deliver 0.407 watt or -3.9 dBW and repeated the frequency response and distortion sweep. It’s pretty easy to see that things got worse, especially at 60 and 70 through 80 hertz. If the speaker were perfectly linear, the lower trace THD trace would increase by 6.07 dB as the upper trace. Our distortion numbers at 50, 200 and 500 hertz are 5.04, 1.77 and 0.31%, respectively. High-frequency distortion was 0.40 and 0.21% at 2 and 4 kHz.

Replacement Speaker Quality
AW-660SP frequency response and total harmonic distortion at 1.61 watts (blue).

I increased the output level by another 7 dB to 1.61 watts. This time, distortion in the higher frequencies increased significantly relative to the bass and midbass frequencies. Now we have 5.18, 1.8 and 0.59% at 50, 200 and 500 hertz. At 2 kHz, distortion was 0.93 and 0.26 at 4 kHz. It was getting easier to hear that the speaker wasn’t enjoying this drive level, and we were barely over 1 watt of power. How about we bump it up again by another sixish decibels?

Replacement Speaker Quality
AW-660SP frequency response and total harmonic distortion at 6.45 watts (yellow).

Things start to go south with a mere 6.45 watts driving this little woofer. We have 11.91% distortion at 50 Hz, 1.67% at 200 Hz and 1.36% at 500 Hz. The upper midrange got quite upset with 2.12% THD at 2 kHz and 0.42% THD at 4 kHz. It wouldn’t be any stretch to say that this speaker was quite upset with this power level.

Replacement Speaker Quality
AW-660SP frequency response and total harmonic distortion at 26.06 watts (orange).

It should be no surprise that things get much worse with an extra 20 watts of power. Distortion numbers are now at 38.19, 2.98, 2.85, 3.85 and 0.86% at our respective test frequencies. It was really easy to hear that this driver was NOT enjoying being driven with this much power, especially at lower frequencies.

Replacement Speaker Quality
A comparison of distortion levels by frequency vs. power sent to the speaker.

Can you imagine how harsh this speaker would sound with more than 2% distortion at 2 kHz when driven with just over 6 watts of power? That would produce 4 and 6 kHz harmonics at a combined level that was only 34 dB below the 2 kHz fundamental. That’d be clearly audible and quite nasty. At 100 Hz, this driver would produce 200 and 300 Hz content, only 30.2 dB (3.09% THD) below the fundamental. Talk about making your music sound muddy!

It’s clear that given the price point and design, this speaker wasn’t designed as a high-performance upgrade. If you’re on a tight budget and need something to replace a damaged or blown speaker, it’s a valid option and is precisely what it was designed for. It would probably be fine if you want to listen to an FM talk radio or AM station. If you want to crank your music and enjoy it at concert-like levels, this isn’t the speaker for you.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Related

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio Tagged With: Civic, Honda, Speaker Distortion, Speaker Quality, Speakers

About Dave MacKinnon

Dave has worked in the mobile electronics industry since 1988 in almost every capacity, including roles as a Retail Salesperson, Installer, Sales Representative, Technical Trainer, and Product Development Manager for some of the largest car audio companies in the world. Dave started his writing career in 2000 as the Technical Editor of a Toronto-based car audio magazine and has reviewed more than 450 products. Formally trained as an Electronics Technician, Dave is considered an industry expert when it comes to explaining how mobile audio components work and has crafted thousands of articles to share that knowledge. He’s currently the Head Writer for 1sixty8 media and the Editor-in-Chief at BestCarAudio.com

Kicker ad
Audison Forza

Save Time and Money!

Our buying guides will help you make educated decisions when upgrading your vehicle. Click the image above to shop our affordable and informative buying guides.

Industry Profiles

Amp Rack

Pinnacle Autosound Audi Q3 Amp Rack and Subs

August 16, 2023 By Dave MacKinnon 

A short while back, we looked at the stunning Audi Q3 demo vehicle built by Pinnacle Autosound in Lake City, Florida. We … [Read More...]

Dodge Challenger

Mobile Enhancement Industry Profile: 2019 Dodge Challenger

July 28, 2023 By Dave MacKinnon 

Brian Mitchell’s name should be familiar if you’ve looked at results of any significant sound quality auto sound … [Read More...]

Press Releases

Sony XAV-9000ES
Sony Electronics Introduces New Mobile ES Car AV Receiver and Power Amplifiers
RDVFL Mighty Mount Press Release
RDV Becomes Exclusive US Distributor for Mighty Mount
New Heise Connect App Goes Live for Smart Devices
RDVFL CarPlay CP1
RDV Releases New CarPlay Hardware Platform
Maserati Radio
RDV Launches Tesla Style Radio for Maserati

Vehicle Insights

2023 BMW X1

2023 BMW X1. Modern Tech Basics.

Ford Raptor R

2023 Ford Raptor R. Trail Beast and Street Beast

Find Facility Near You

Subscribe to BestCarAudio via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to BestCarAudio.com and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Popular Categories

  • Car Audio
  • Window Tint
  • Remote Car Starters
  • Vehicle Insights
  • Radar Detectors

Supporting Manufacturers

  • Arc Audio
  • Compustar
  • Hertz
  • Momento
  • Rockford Fosgate
  • Sony

Contact

  • Editorial
  • General
  • Advertise
  • Dealer Locator Guidelines

Miscellaneous

  • Profile Request
  • Press Release Guidelines

Sign up for our newsletter today. Opt out at any time with 1 click.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

BestCarAudio.com is a product of 1sixty8 media, inc. · Copyright © 2023 1sixty8 media, inc. · Privacy Policy · Website by 1sixty8 media, inc. · Log in

 

Loading Comments...
 

    x
    x