BestCarAudio.com

Showcasing the Best in the Mobile Enhancement Industry

Showcasing the Best in the Mobile Enhancement Industry
  • Articles
    • Bluetooth
    • Car Audio
    • Motorcycle Audio
    • Navigation
    • Remote Starter
    • Satellite Radio
    • Smartphone Integration
    • Test Drive Product Reviews
    • Vehicle Insights
  • Industry Profiles
    • Installation Profiles
    • Installer Profiles
    • Retailer Profiles
    • Vendor Profiles
  • Products
  • Dealer Locator
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • 0 items

Why Do Car Audio Companies Hide Product Specs?

April 22, 2020 By Dave MacKinnon

Car Audio Specs

If you’ve read some of the more technical articles here at BestCarAudio.com, then you’ll know that I hold the analysis and understanding of product specifications in high regard. Whether it’s something simple like a subwoofer mounting depth, the preamp voltage of a source unit or the power measurements of an amplifier, having access to accurate information is important. More in-depth information about signal-to-noise ratio and distortion can tell us a lot about the quality of a product. So why is it that many car audio companies seem to hide their specifications?

Do We Need a Standard for Specifications?

There should always be a standard by which we can compare specifications. The Consumer Technology Association (CTA) has created standards for measuring car audio amplifier power (CTA-2006), for defining the requirements for car audio wiring (CTA-2015) and for speaker specification (CTA-2013). In varying amounts, these standards allow consumers to compare the features of products or know that the information provided on specification sheets is accurate.

The details of the CTA standards aren’t available to the public. If you want to know how the signal-to-noise ratio of a car audio amplifier is measured, then you have to purchase the $58 CTA-2006-B document. While the information should be comparable from one brand to another, not knowing the details of the test conditions puts the relevance of the numbers into question.

Car Audio Specs
Launched in 2014, the Signature Edition amplifiers from ARC Audio remain a benchmark in the industry. You can hear their clarity and detail as soon as the music starts playing.

Speaker and Subwoofer Specifications

In terms of installing a subwoofer, two basic pieces of information are required: mounting depth and the required cutout diameter of the driver. It seems that most companies provide that information on their websites or in the owner’s manual or spec sheet. Of course, the nominal impedance of the driver (2 or 4 ohms, for example) is also readily available.

For those who want to make sure that the performance of the planed subwoofer system will suit their needs, analysis of the subwoofer in the chosen enclosure is recommended. To accomplish this, access to Thiele/Small parameters that describe the electromechanical characteristics of the driver is required. This information can be used with speaker enclosure simulation software like BassBox Pro or Term-Pro to predict frequency response.

Where things become tricky is that some companies are stingy with their specifications. They leave out important information necessary to complete a detailed simulation that includes driver excursion predictions that may affect power handling. Beyond the Vas, Fs, Qts, Re and Sd specs, specific information about electrical Q (Qes), mechanical Q (Qms), linear excursion (Xmax), moving mass (Mms) and the force factor (BL) should be included. Likewise, for high(er)-frequency simulation, accurate voice coil inductance (Le) measurements should be provided. Some companies offer very good enclosure designs, but having access to Thiele/Small information means that educated installers can design custom subwoofer and speaker solutions and predict response very accurately.

I measure the Thiele/Small parameters of every speaker and subwoofer I work with. I use the Woofer Tester 2 from Smith & Larson Audio. It’s relatively inexpensive at $160. Other companies have, of course, copied its design. Another option for testing driver parameters is the IM-SG+ from D’Amore Engineering. This handheld impedance meter doesn’t require a computer, so it’s completely portable. You will have to do some math with the information it provides to determine the T/S specs.

Car Audio Specs
The IM-SG+ from D’Amore Engineering allows users to measure the impedance of a speaker at different frequencies.

Almost none of this information describes the quality of the subwoofer or a speaker. It doesn’t tell us about suspension nonlinearities. We don’t know if the cone, dust cap or surround have resonance issues. We don’t know if the voice coil is centered (vertically) in the gap. We have no idea about the position-based inductance characteristics of the driver. It’s this information that helps differentiate the mediocre from the fantastic. Advanced testing using equipment from companies like Klippel provides some insight into this information. If you are curious about this, check out Erin Hardison’s website.

It would be amazing if speaker manufacturers would include distortion vs. frequency plots of their speakers. Sadly, none do.

Car Audio Specs
This graph shows the frequency response (in black) of a high-end 2.5-inch midrange driver at an output level of 90 dB. The colored curves represent first- through fourth-order harmonic distortion levels. Image courtesy of www.erinsaudiocorner.com.

Amplifier Specs

Most of us who are into car audio know about the CTA-2006 (formerly CEA-2006) amplifier specification standard. Companies like Harman (JBL and Infinity) and Rockford Fosgate worked hard in the early 2000s to extol the virtues of publishing comparable power and noise specifications. While most online specs follow the requirements of using 14.4 volts to feed the amp and keep the distortion in the output signal below 1%, many still don’t follow the spec for defining noise at an output level of 1 watt.

Inflated signal-to-noise specs taken at peak power do little to determine the suitability of an amplifier for a specific application. Likewise, the current standard doesn’t include a defined gain ratio, so everyone tests their products with the gain turned all the way down. The CTA committee is working on yet another version of the standard, called CTA-2006-C. Hopefully, more companies will use this revised standard once it’s available.

Car Audio Specs
The Audison Thesis HV Venti is one of the most exotic amplifiers ever created. It also happens to be capable of producing more than 1,600 watts of power.

One topic I geek out over is the discussion of amplifier distortion. Distortion is the addition of unwanted information to the audio signal. The amount of added information is what separates the good from the mediocre. As we’ve mentioned in other articles, for most Class AB amps, distortion decreases as power increases. So, taking a distortion measurement at, say, 75% of maximum power may yield the lowest printable number. In reality, distortion should be measured at an output level that is more common to regular listening. The 1-watt-into-4-ohms spec that CTA-2006 uses for noise measurements might be ideal. Even better, distortion graphs tell the tale with impressive clarity. Armed with this information, shoppers can directly compare the quality of an amplifier.

Car Audio Specs
Measured by Garry Springgay at Cogent Audio Labs, this graph shows the distortion characteristics of a high-power subwoofer amplifier.

Why Do Companies Hide Their Specs?

The reality is, no single company makes the best of everything. Some make great speakers, some make great amplifiers and a few make great processors. The marketing teams for each of these companies work hard to sell their products.

Car Audio Specs
The Brax MX4 Pro boasts some impressive specifications. Those numbers translate into a clearly audible difference in performance quality.

Having tested and reviewed products from almost every reputable car audio brand throughout my career, I can tell you without a shadow of a doubt that they are occasionally lying when they say solution XYZ is the best. I suppose it’s their job, but I’d prefer that they put that marketing effort into designing a premium product instead of relying on marketing fluff to make something mediocre seem appealing.

If you measure something, the results are absolute. If you have a defined an accurate standard for those measurements, and other companies follow that standard, the results are comparable. This is the right way – an ethical and honest way. If a car audio company wants to claim to be the best, they should be able to provide supporting evidence.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Related

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio Tagged With: Amplifiers, BassBox Pro, Class AB, Consumer Technology Association, CTA-2006, D'Amore Engineering, Digital Signal Processors, Harman, Infinity, JBL, Rockford Fosgate, Speakers, Subwoofers, Term-Pro

About Dave MacKinnon

Dave has worked in the mobile electronics industry since 1988 in almost every capacity, including roles as a Retail Salesperson, Installer, Sales Representative, Technical Trainer, and Product Development Manager for some of the largest car audio companies in the world. Dave started his writing career in 2000 as the Technical Editor of a Toronto-based car audio magazine and has reviewed more than 450 products. Formally trained as an Electronics Technician, Dave is considered an industry expert when it comes to explaining how mobile audio components work and has crafted thousands of articles to share that knowledge. He’s currently the Head Writer for 1sixty8 media and the Editor-in-Chief at BestCarAudio.com

Audison Forza

Save Time and Money!

Our buying guides will help you make educated decisions when upgrading your vehicle. Click the image above to shop our affordable and informative buying guides.

Industry Profiles

ENORMIS Mobile Specialties

Mobile Enhancement Retailer Spotlight: ENORMIS Mobile Specialties

June 3, 2022 By Dave MacKinnon 

When it comes to mobile enhancement retailers, ENORMIS Mobile Specialties in Erie, Pennsylvania, is unlike any other … [Read More...]

Alpine Tesla

Mobile Enhancement Industry Profile: 2018 Tesla Model S

March 21, 2022 By Dave MacKinnon 

A Honda Civic Si, Acura RSX, Mini Speedster, BMW X5, the Sinister 6 and the Imprint RLS – if you recognize the pattern … [Read More...]

Press Releases

Firstech Launches Momento M7 Three-Channel Car Dash Camera
iBeam
iBEAM® Ships New Tailgate Handle Cameras, Micro Camera, and Window Mount
Firstech, ADS Announce Remote Start Partnership
iBEAM Commercial Wireless Systems
iBEAM Ships New Commercial Wireless Rearview System and Monitor
Firstech KP2
Firstech Unveils New “KP2” Keyless Touchpad Accessory for Remote Start

Vehicle Insights

2023 Cadillac CT5

2023 Cadillac CT5 Premium Luxury. Super Cruisin’!

2022 BMW i4 eDrive40. Electrifying the 4 Series

Find Facility Near You

Subscribe to BestCarAudio via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to BestCarAudio.com and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Popular Categories

  • Car Audio
  • Window Tint
  • Remote Car Starters
  • Vehicle Insights
  • Radar Detectors

Supporting Manufacturers

  • Arc Audio
  • Compustar
  • Hertz
  • Momento
  • Rockford Fosgate
  • Sony

Contact

  • Editorial
  • General
  • Advertise
  • Dealer Locator Guidelines

Forms

  • Profile Request

Sign up for our newsletter today. Opt out at any time with 1 click.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

BestCarAudio.com is a product of 1sixty8 media, inc. · Copyright © 2023 1sixty8 media, inc. · Privacy Policy · Website by 1sixty8 media, inc. · Log in

 

Loading Comments...